"No longer the unwilling component of an unprecedented attempt at political unification, but
independent, standing or falling on our own merits"
That is Why today the prime Minister is so right to flash some steel — to unsheathe a section of the blade that might soon be used to cut the rope and set Britain free. Free to make our own laws and our own trade deals; to have impact in the world commensurate with our own abilities, no longer believing that we can somehow puff ourselves up and "punch above our weight" by contriving to call the shots among 28 nations in the smoke-free corridors of Brussels. No longer to sacrifice parliamentary democracy for diplomatic "influence"; no longer the subset of a superstate; no longer the unwilling component of a unique and unprecedented attempt at political unification, but independent, standing or falling on our own merits. David Cameron is making it clear, in his long-awaited speech, that if he doesn't get a satisfactory result in those negotiations, then he could lead the Out campaign; and in that great release of pent-up Eurosceptic energy there can be little doubt that he would be victorious. And then what? Well, there would unquestionably be a scratchy period. There would be anxiety in Washington, where they like the convenience of having their closest ally round the table in the El J. There would be nervousness among some of the big international investors in the UK who would not want to be shut out from the Single Market — and those fears would have to be allayed. In many EU countries — and this is a point that weighs with me — there would be real shock and dismay from those who think that Britain has much to contribute, and who know in their hearts that without active British engagement, the history of Europe in the last 100 years would have been (to put it mildly) a whole lot worse. But is that enough in 2015, 70 years after the end of the last war? Must British influence be expressed through this supranational body, with all its anti-democratic practices? If we are to be successful in this negotiation — and stay in a reformed EU — then our friends and partners must understand that we are serious in our aims. The Prime Minister is rightly calling for reform that will give this country back control of its borders; that will stop the one-way ratchet towards ever closer union; that will curtail the profusion of regulation; that will stop the eurozone countries from bullying those EU countries who do not use the euro and probably never will.We need somehow to persuade our friends of what their own electorates are telling them — that it is better and more democratic to ensure that as much decision making as possible is handed back to national parliaments, and we need the negotiations to give effect to that ambition as well. It can work. I am sure that David Cameron can get what he wants by the end of next year. And if our friends are so irrational as to say no, and we vote accordingly to come out, is that really the end of the
story? Look at all previous "no" votes. The Danes voted no. The French, the Irish, even the Dutch they have all at one stage or other put two fingers up to the treaties. They are still members. The other countries just had to make the necessary adjustments.
"In the coming campaign we will hear torrents of drivel from all the people who traditionally warn about us about leaving'
Indeed, you could argue that the only language our friends understand is an initial no — and that is the only thing that will really bring them to the table, make them focus on the need for reform. Britain's relationship with Europe has already changed, in the sense that we are not members of the dominant political project — the single currency, with all its further erosions Of democracy. We are already members of a very different club from France and Germany. But there are other members of that club; others who are not in the euro but who want free trade. It would be no bad thing to lead that group, to formalize what is already a semi-divorce. One thing is sure: in the coming campaign we will hear absolute torrents of drivel from all the people who traditionally warn about us not being included in some European project — big business, the CBI, the Europhiles in Parliament. Remember: they were wrong about the ERM, they were wrong about the euro and they are already exaggerating the downsides of leaving.
We want to stay in, but not at any price. David Cameron is right to make that clear.
Excerpted from David Cameron is right ro make ir clear' withou' a deal. Brilain will leave the EU - Telegraph
Works Cited:
Johnson, Boris. "David Cameron Is Right to Make It Clear: Without a Deal, Britain Will Leave the EU." The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, 9 Nov. 2015. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.
Response:
The European Union (EU) is going to have to make compromises and formulate a better deal for Britain, because at this point, Britain doesn't seem to be messing around. From initial remarks, it seemed that Britain may have been bluffing or just trying to squeeze a better deal out from the EU, but now Britain is actually considering of opting out of the EU. This single decision would be a game changer pertaining to international relations as Britain is a huge trading engine for the EU. Also the US, being one of Britain's biggest allies, will now have to encounter a different face of the EU without Britain at their side. Britain also being an economic world power, will have to decide how this decision will affect independent businesses and internal trade, which in turn effects exports and imports from other countries. Britain is on the brink of their heavy decision, and whichever side wins, will absolutely affect the country and international relations.
In response to bias, it wasn't too noticeable as both sides were clearly outlined and the author wasn't leaning to one side or the other.
We want to stay in, but not at any price. David Cameron is right to make that clear.
Excerpted from David Cameron is right ro make ir clear' withou' a deal. Brilain will leave the EU - Telegraph
Works Cited:
Johnson, Boris. "David Cameron Is Right to Make It Clear: Without a Deal, Britain Will Leave the EU." The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, 9 Nov. 2015. Web. 09 Nov. 2015.
Response:
The European Union (EU) is going to have to make compromises and formulate a better deal for Britain, because at this point, Britain doesn't seem to be messing around. From initial remarks, it seemed that Britain may have been bluffing or just trying to squeeze a better deal out from the EU, but now Britain is actually considering of opting out of the EU. This single decision would be a game changer pertaining to international relations as Britain is a huge trading engine for the EU. Also the US, being one of Britain's biggest allies, will now have to encounter a different face of the EU without Britain at their side. Britain also being an economic world power, will have to decide how this decision will affect independent businesses and internal trade, which in turn effects exports and imports from other countries. Britain is on the brink of their heavy decision, and whichever side wins, will absolutely affect the country and international relations.
In response to bias, it wasn't too noticeable as both sides were clearly outlined and the author wasn't leaning to one side or the other.
Good Job on summarizing the article. I think you have a good idea what is going on with this situation in Britain and I also agree that the author of this article was just stating the facts rather than leaning left or right. In my personal opinion, despite my subtle knowledge in British politics, I think David Cameron is quite adamant when it comes to Britain's demands I don't think his proposal of leaving the EU is a joke. Overall, good article and good summary.
ReplyDeleteThis is an interesting article. If Britain does decide to leave the EU, then a lot of relations will change in Europe and other parts of the world. I think you were right in regards to bias, and i think the EU will have some things to consider, as well as Britain. Good article and response, and it will be interesting to see how this plays out in the near future.
ReplyDeleteThis topic is really interesting because of the huge changes that would come if Britain actually went through with this. I agree that there did not appear to be much bias from the authors point of view and it will be interesting to see how this whole thing plays out. Great job!
ReplyDeleteThe affects that would follow Britain leaving the EU are monumental. I don't know, at this point, if it would be a good thing or a bad thing, but I do know that Britain's international relationships will be totally altered as well as its relationship with its neighboring countries. This is an incredibly thought provoking article, relatively lacking in bias, and you showed a clear understanding, not just of this particular article, but the situation as a whole. Great job!
ReplyDeleteThe EU represents a huge part in the decision making in both political, social and economical issues. If Britain decides to step out, there will be some heavy consequences on both sides. Since Britain will no longer benefit from the advantages granted form being apart of the EU but on the other side have the ability to make their own rules and decisions. This is a tight spot, but David Cameroon has proven to be a great leader and his positive influences has greatly defined the nation Britain is today. Good job on the article!
ReplyDeleteThe loss of Britain would indeed be a considerable source of change for the European Union. It is a commonly held belief that this change would most likely be a detrimental one. Although the article is written in an incredibly confident tone, it does not convey the same emotion when it discusses the confidence that Britain has in seceding from the EU. The author of the article seems rather confident that Britain is going to be well off as a separated sector from the EU, this however is something that can only be determined with time. It is something that is going to be very interesting to observe in the coming months (particularly if Britain does secede form the EU).
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that Britain's decision is important regarding the chaos that would break out internationally especially among their allies as Britain's decision could bring more hostility towards them. I also agree that there seems to be no bias to either sides.Great job!
ReplyDeleteInteresting article and great response. The situation at hand seems to be a very difficult decision for the British to make. Not only do the outcomes seem unpredictable, but both the external and internal relations of Britain would be greatly affected, and you make a great response with a lucid explanation about this. I agree with Eman that the author of the article seems rather confident that Britain will be better off when separated from the EU and would also be interested in what would actually happen.
ReplyDeleteWhat an interesting article! We think that this is an event that everyone must know. This article makes us to think deeply since this little change, Britain leaving the EU, can make a huge impact in the world. For long time, EU have been together helping each other. It is also important the decision of Britain toward other nations but also there can be a little tension between them. Well, as you said, Britain also has world's economic power and it will affect all other EU nations. Starting this point, the world should see what will happen with them and what's the decision of Britain and solution of other EU nations. Thank you for the article!
ReplyDeleteInteresting article, and good response. The chages the EU and Britain would experience if they go through with this would be colossal. I agree that Britain must remember that since it is a world power this decision will affect the world, mainly in trade, as you stated. Your response shows you understand this situation, which is important in responding to an article. Good job overall.
ReplyDeleteLike a lot of people said before me, this is a really interesting article. For me personally it was a bit unexpected and that's probably because I don't really pay attention to what's going on on that side of the world. Anyways, I also think that Britain breaking free from the EU would bring a lot of complications especially when it comes to things like international trade and relations. I agree with you in saying that the article did not seem biased, and I also think you weren't very biased either. Good job on the response and analysis of the article. :)
ReplyDeleteInteresting article and good response. The topic of the issue comes as a surprise as I was not aware of Britain's consideration of leaving the EU. If Britain does decided to leave the EU, it would have both economic and social effects world wide but I don't see this as a reason to panic. Given the current relation between Britain and the European Nations, I doubt that Britain will not be offered another deal. Only the future will tell.
ReplyDeleteBritain has always been hesitant when it comes to true integration with the European Union. Culturally and financially, it differs widely from the rest of the Continent and finding itself inextricably tied to an economic sinkhole, it's likely to consider itself better off alone. In any case, Cameron is bound to exploit the opportunity to either one, force a Britain-friendly agreement down the throat of a desperate European Parliament or two, leave altogether.
ReplyDeleteAs for the article itself, I would argue that, from the author's diction and overall presentation, he is clearly for a separation from the Union.
This article was truly fascinating in light of the changes our world is experiencing today. If Britain chooses to leave, then the repercussions would impact us all. It's a powerful country and decisions have to be made carefully and wisely. Great response and article choice!
ReplyDeleteAs stated numerous times before, the UK leaving the EU will cause significant shifts globally both economically and politcally. As a european citizen it will cause changes even closer to home than most making it slightly frightening because of how little the world has been responding but whether this threat of leaving will actually happen, no one knows. Overall this is an interesting article and i agree that it will cause huge shifts, but who knows maybe for the better?
ReplyDeleteGreat article!! I feel like you did a really good overview of the article! As others have also commented, Britain leaving the EU will cause a great amount of changes both internationally and inside the country. It seems that the EU will have to consider things more seriously as you have said. But like the previous comments, no one will know what happens until Britain actually decides to leave the EU
ReplyDeleteInteresting article choice, a problem which involves most of Europe as a whole and could affect a large portion of the world at large. From my perspective, there did indeed seem to be some bias from the very beginning. Being a British news site, the journalist displayed Britain as the most necessary member of the EU, and that the other EU nations should try to do everything in their power to keep Britain included. The article stated that Britain is doing what's right, sharpening their sword in preparation for a game-changing decision should no change come about the EU. Should Britain leave, the gap that will be left in the European Union might very well be too large to cover up or fill. Instead, that gap may swallow the EU as a whole as they loose a large power player who is the current edge to the sword that is the European Union. So I very much agree with your statements, everything will be affected should no change happen and Britain decides to quit.
ReplyDeleteIt was an interesting article choice in the fact that this is not a normal occurrence. I do believe that the author was just spewing facts left and right. However i doubt that Mr. Camaroon will have the guts in to leave. When (if) Great Britian does infact leave the EU, that is one of the largest chunks of the EU gone. The EU cannot remain stable without Britian, so i really have doubts that this threat is genuine
ReplyDeleteJosh, you bring up an interesting point because I'm sure that the EU would disagree with you. The EU isn't actually fully reliant on Great Britain, although they do play a big role in the organization. Interesting response.
DeleteNice article! We agree with your point of view about the issue and we thinks Britain is getting serious. The European Union may be affected in massive amounts if Britain decides to leave. In our opinion Britain should not get everything that they want just because they are a huge part of the EU. They should get an advantage but a not so big one. This is a serious issue and the EU should do everything they can to fix it since it will affect the whole world.
ReplyDeleteAlfonso Calderon
Nacho Flores
Adrian Mijares
Emilio Antun
Fascinating response, because I never thought about the situation from that point of view. You're right, Great Britain shouldn't just get an improved deal just because of their status, but I think we have to understand their side of the world. They want a better deal, because they recognize that with or without the EU, they can positively thrive. Nice input.
DeleteBritain is not a joke country, they are constantly and permanently since the First Wars the main country in many aspects, and a major influence in the world economy. When the EU tries to not make a deal and see for the interests of Britain, they will intercede anymore, they have for so many time, and their culture tells them to put their country first. They have mad embassy arrangements to try and fit, but not anymore, they are in the verge of not being a puppet anymore form the EU, but instead what it tends to be, a world power that is sustained by the United States and with many countries in Africa and the Middle East at their hands. Even though they are a small territory, they have a lot on their manipulation, concepts that are trending and relevant in the present world issues, and the new world Agenda.
ReplyDeleteSebastian Drexel A01193602
Nazario Assad A01193704
Ricardo Martinez A01193661
Alex Garcia A01193623
Emiliano Cantu A01193897
This article is interesting because of many British reasons of leaving the EU, It is interesting knowing they want to leave it since they are kind of different from other EU countries, like in their currency which is pounds. Our personal opinion is that although they want to leave, this will not cause a big difference, because as said, Britain is already a bit apart from the EU in many aspects.
ReplyDeleteBernardo Rdz
Roegelio Elizondo
Daniel Sada
We really think this article is really interesting since Britain is a country with a lot of power, and as well we can say that it has a very dominant economy around the world. They article states the idea of people from Britain leaving but as we see the case Britain is nos directly involved with the EU buy does have some aspects in common, including territory. So we this this would cause certain disturbance but not so much since they have been creating their own economy and society since long time ago.
ReplyDeleteMariana gonzalez
Mariana Paez
Julieta Galvan
Daniela Garza
Nice article and great response to it. We think that Britain should really think carefully about their following actions because what can be their best decision, can also be their worst decision. Leaving the EU can really affect Britain's economy because they will be independent exporters and importers without the involvement on the countries of the EU, but it will also affect the EU because Britain is one of the major countries that have great economical influence due to its high imports and exports. It can really benefit, which is not likely for neither party, or it can harm both of them, which is the most likely if the terms from both parties do not come to a conclusion and they do not sign the deal. At first, the bias is towards Britain because it talks about the privileges it could have if it leaves the EU, but then it describes the various outcomes and the huge risk that both parties are making.
ReplyDeletePatricio Garza
Alejandro Zertuche
Patricio Guerra
Gerardo Estrada
Santiago Gama
Great article! We think that this current event is really interesting and that people should now what’s going on now with Britain and the EU because this situation and the possible outcomes could affect the trade and economy of the world, and even create tension between other EU members. It’s a serious condition and only time will tell what Britain decides. People should be aware of this situation and countries should be ready for future effects that this could cause if Britain leaves the EU. Good job with your response, it’s clear that you fully understand the situation and it made us get a wider view of the whole picture.
ReplyDeleteKatia Colyer
DeleteAle Garrido
Ari Astrid
Silvana Dávalos
Ale Gzz
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDaniela Serrato A01193607
ReplyDeleteAndrea Jimenez A01193713
Maria Quintanilla A01193685
Andrea Pasquel A01193580
Paola Suess A01193770
This is a very important article an it has a great response. This is not only going to affect Britain, but also all the countries in the EU and the US because of their alliance with Britain. Britain has a very important role in the EU because they are one of the countries that have a greater influence in the economy of EU. People and all members should be aware of what the future consequences would be. We found interesting the fact that Britain wants to leave because they feel kind of different from the other members of the EU. It could either be good for Britain or harmful for both parties. Great article and response!!
ReplyDeleteBritain is taking a very decisive step regarding the European union and its citizens. This decision has been taken because they are tired that a lot of countries that are not at their level are taking decisions that are not 100% benefitting them. They think that it is better for them to separate and become a free country with their own laws and their own coin system. They have treaties of free trade with US and will be continuing with countries of the European union.
Fernanda Jasso - A01193939
Sabrina Cantu - A01193783
Arlette Rodriguez - A01193727
Daniela Gonzalez - A01328004
This is a great article and a good response for it. Britain is one of the stronger bodies in the EU and this means that it has a higher economic impact than other countries, and therefore taking these decision will cause for Britain to lose relations with other countries and have some problems in imports and exports. I think Britain should consider their decisions a little more because it doesn't only affect them but the rest of the world
ReplyDeleteBenjamin Cavada- A01194065
Isabel Leal -A01193824
Marifer Gutierrez- A01193625
Chalo Gonzalez- A01194662
This is a very interesting article! In our personal opinion we think David Cameron is really taking into consideration leaving the EU. We think this decision will affect the economy of the European Union since Britain is a huge trading engine. We believe that before taking any decision everyone should really think about the consequences of the decision taken. This was a great article to talk about because it is important to learn and know about what is happening around the world.
ReplyDeleteValeria Garza
Alma Torres
Brenda Quiroz
Natalia de Alba
The famous "brexit" would represent a catastrophe to the whole globe, many say. But still, if they stay, a catastrophe could also happen, since the EU is going down with all of their current issues, from Greece's unpaid chaos, to the out-of-hand refugee crisis. Britain is affected negatively in both options. An exit, would mean an end to al of those free trades and ease of diplomatic issues. But staying, would be like a Captain staying on his sinking boat, except Britain isn't actually the captain of EU. We consider that EU will colapse, either soon enough, or in a near future. We think that Britain should leave, and remain unaffected in the sinkage of the EU. We consider this will be the greater good. This is a dilemma that mainly has 2 viewing points. Liberalist and Realist. The liberalist being that the EU will be saved if Britain Stays (Highly unlikely), and the Realist being that the EU will collapse, with or without Britain.
ReplyDeleteBernardo Montemayor
Rodolfo Piñeyro
Diego Treviño.
Mauricio Morales
We believe that this is a very well written article because you make us look at both perspectives and the consequences of every option that the country has. In our opinion Britain has always been one of the biggest economies and most influential countries so they have a very strong government and a huge development advantage over other countries, so if they think that being a part of the union is holding them back then maybe they should go their separate ways. They don`t have the same currency, traditions and many other things, they are a very independent country and other countries in the union are in a very bad shape so they are going to drag Britain down sooner or later. We think its not fair that it is almost as if the EU depended on Britain, they should only worry about themselves not the whole european region. Basically if its not in the countries best interest to stay part of the union, they should leave.
ReplyDeleteEugenia Odriozola
Karla Garcia
Isabella Gomez
Gabriela Gomez
This is a great article. Your response showed the overall summary of the article and your opinion clearly. I agree with your point that Britain is not longer bluffing. Their decision will impact EU greatly both ways. Leaving EU is not an easy option and staying doesn't seem to be easy anymore. Whatever choice that Britain makes, I hope it is wise choice.
ReplyDeleteBritain is very valuable to the EU but Britain has seemingly nothing to gain by staying with the EU. This is the great dilemma that is keeping Europe on its toes. Syrian Refugees, Greek economy and terrorism in every corner are all part of Europe's 99 problems. Britain's consideration of leaving the EU is just another 1. Whichever decision Britain takes, everything will change for the British population. Probably the other members of the EU will do anything to make Britain stay since it is such an important part of the European economy. Whatever happens, we hope that Britain's leader makes the right choice.
ReplyDeleteEugenio Granja
Abraham Trad
Eduardo Vazquez
Sergio Durazo
We are really agree with your point of view of Britain, you make clear what both points of view see and express. If Britain leaves there will be a lot of impact all around the world since they are a great economically. We just hope that the leaders has the best chooise not only for them but to all of us
ReplyDeleteDavid Valdes
Santiago Chavez
Mauricio Morales
Ian Tattersfield